Despite slow property sales, government coffers have been considerably boosted, particularly by the 3% stamp duty surcharge.

  • By

  • What’s the latest?

    A record £9.56bn in stamp duty was handed over to the Government in 2017, despite subdued property sales.

    The latest figures from HM Revenue & Customs shows that the amount the Treasury makes from the tax increased by 16% during last year, to stand at more than twice the level it was at in 2012.

    That rise came despite the number of homes changing hands, which were liable for stamp duty, edging ahead by just 1% during the year.

    But while stamp duty might be a nice earner for the Government, commentators have warned that it acts as a tax on mobility and is distorting the property market.

    Why is this happening?

    Some of the increase in the total stamp duty take can be accounted for by rising house prices, with property values increasing by 2.6% during 2017, compared with the previous year.

    Higher house prices not only mean people pay more of the tax, as it is linked to a property’s value, but it also pushes more homes into higher stamp duty bands.

    However, a bigger contributor is likely to be the 3% stamp duty surcharge that was introduced in April 2016 for people buying second homes, including buy-to-let properties.

    The surcharge contributed more than £2.1bn to government coffers last year, accounting for more than a fifth of the total, with 2017 the first full calendar year during which it has been in force.

    Who does it affect?

    Changes to stamp duty have had a significant impact on certain sectors of the market.

    Since the 3% surcharge on second homes came into effect, lending to buy-to-let investors has fallen steeply.

    Estate agents have also attributed the slowdown at the top end of the property market to the 10% stamp duty rate charged on homes costing £925,001, while a 12% rate is imposed on properties costing more than £1.5m.

    On the plus side, the Chancellor announced in November’s Budget that first-time buyers purchasing homes costing up to £300,000 would be exempt from the tax.

    This move prompted Rob Walker, spokesman for PwC, to say that, "in theory, 95% of first time buyers are winners from the removal of stamp duty on first time purchases".

    But, he warned: “Currently higher stamp duty rates further up the housing ladder dissuades people from upsizing, resulting in a shortage of homes coming on the market to satisfy first-time buyer demand, and ultimately limiting the number of people who can take advantage of this landmark announcement by the Chancellor.” 

    Sounds interesting. Tell me more.

    The London School of Economics blamed stamp duty for contributing to the UK’s 'dysfunctional property market', in a report compiled for the Family Building Society.

    It said stamp duty discouraged people from downsizing because of the tax bill they would face, while it also encouraged families who wanted more space to extend their existing property rather than move home.

    It also claimed the tax was an impediment to social mobility, as it acted as a disincentive to people to relocate to take up a new job.

    Meanwhile, separate research by Royal London, a mutual life, pensions and investment company, found HMRC had had to refund £231m to people since April 2016, after they were wrongly charged the 3% surcharge.

    The group said the charge was applied to people who completed a purchase on a home before selling their existing property, leading to them being able to claim a refund once their existing home had been sold.

    It has called for the system to be reformed, so that second home stamp duty is not collected for routine house sales and purchases, except where there is no linked sale, and the intention is clearly to become a second home owner.

    Helen Morrissey, personal finance specialist at Royal London, said: "Taxes like the second home stamp duty were designed to clamp down on buy-to-let landlords, not people whose house sale took longer than they expected. Moving house is already a stressful enough activity, without having to pay thousands in extra tax to HMRC, and then have to claim it back."

    Top 3 takeaways

    • Homebuyers handed over a record £9.56bn in stamp duty to the Government in 2017
    • The amount the Treasury makes from the tax increased by 16% during the year
    • The rise came despite the number of homes changing hands which were liable for stamp duty edging ahead by just 1% during the year

    What are your thoughts on the record amount of stamp duty earned by the Treasury? Tell us by posting a comment below...

    * DISQUS *
    comments powered by Disqus